A Study o f Predictive Factors i n t he Outcome o f Necrotizing Fasciitis i n Patients of Sepsis


Assistant Professor, General Surgery, Osmania General Hospital, Hyderabad, Telangana, India
Final Year Post Graduate, Department of Surgery, Osmania Medical College and Hospital, Hyderabad, Telangana, India

Abstract

Background: Necrotizing fasciitis is an infection occurring in the deep fascial layers. It is a progressive infection. The diagnosis of necrotizing fasciitis is usually clinical and is important to find it early as it is a fast spreading infection. Necrotizing fasciitis occurs as a result of necrosis of skin and subcutaneous layer. The aim of the study is to assess factors which will help in clinching the diagnosis of Necrotizing Fasciitis and to identify factors responsible for morbidity and mortality. The study was hospital based observational study conducted for 2 years from May 2017- June 2019 on 30 patients with necrotizing fasciitis at Department of general surgery, Osmania General Hospital. Subjects and Methods: Clinical and anatomical findings rendered initial diagnosis. The patient's details have been noted. Detailed patient interview on history and other comorbid conditions was conducted. Bacteriological culture is done. Following initial debridement, the wound was inspected regularly and subsequent debridement was done periodically whenever necessary. Results: Majority of the patients were males, 80% and the rest 20% were females. In 56.66% of the patients the site of NF was perineum and in the rest 43.33% of the patients it was in the extremities. The type of bacterial culture done was polyculture in majority 90% of the patients and monoculture was done in the rest 10% of the patients. 30% of the patients tested positive for NF and rest 70% were found to be negative with NF. The mortality rate was 30% and morbidity rate was 10%. Conclusion: Effective and vigorous surgical debridement, often in multiple sessions, supplemented by adequate antibiotics and supportive treatment, is the key to a successful result with necrotizing fasciitis.

Keywords

Necrotizing Fasciitis, Mortality, Morbidity, Perineum, Extremities

Introduction

Necrotizing fasciitis (NF) is a rare medical and surgical emergency. It is a rapidly progressing severe disorder of soft tissue with significant skin necrosis, subcutaneous tissues, and superficial fascia or muscles. Necrotizing fasciitis is an infection occurring in the deep fascial layers. It is a progressive infection. The diagnosis of necrotizing fasciitis is usually clinical and is important to find it early as it is a fast spreading infection. Necrotizing fasciitis occurs as a result of necrosis of skin and subcutaneous layer. In some cases, there will be necrosis of underlying muscles causing necrotizing myositis. Necrotizing fasciitis often spreads by direct spread. In severe cases, the microorganisms can spread via blood vessel and lymphatics resulting in sepsis and shock.

Bisno et al. [1] described it as a deep-seated tissue infection and superficial fascia that leads to progressive degradation of the subcutaneous tissue. There are no pathognomonic signs indicating the presence of NF at the early stages. There are wide range of symptoms and indications of NF like vesicles, edema, bullae, cellulitis, erythema, crepitus, and fever. Patients are seldom diagnosed with cellulitis before accelerated decomposition is detected. The complications are typically severe sepsis and death. Complications include severe sepsis and mortality. Necrotizing fasciitis is more common in the elderly age group > 50 years of age, but it can occur in virtually every age group including infants, and healthy adults can also be affected. Due to the increased incidence of diabetes and other immunocompromised conditions, the prevalence of necrotizing fasciitis has dramatically increased.

S ubjects and M ethods

Place of Study

This study was conducted at Department Of General Surgery, Osmania General Hospital, Hyderabad. Telangana.

Type of Study

This was hospital based observational study.

Sample Collection

Sample Size: 30

Sampling Methods

Consecutive patients.

Inclusion Criteria

All patients admitted with Necrotizing Fasciitis were included in the study.

Exclusion Criteria

Patients with Non-Necrotizing soft tissue infections were excluded from study (e.g. Cellulitis, abscess).

Statistical Analysis

Data were presented in the form of statistical tables and charts. SPSS software version 20 was used for statistical analysis.

Ethical Approval

Approval was taken from the Institutional Ethics Committee prior to commencement of the study.

Patients presenting with features of necrotizing fasciitis were admitted in the general surgery ward of the Osmania medical college. Clinical and anatomical findings rendered initial diagnosis. The patient's details have been noted. Detailed patient interview on history and other comorbid conditions was conducted. bacteriological culture is done. Following initial debridement, the wound was inspected regularly and subsequent debridement were done periodically whenever necessary. And dressing was done using povidone iodine and saline gauze. After the wound is fit, patient undergone split skin graft surgery for raw area.

Results

Table 1: Distribution of patients across age groups, gender, site of NF and frequency
Age in years Frequency Percent
20-29 2 6.66%
30-39 4 13.33%
40-49 11 36.66%
50-59 6 20.00%
>60 7 23.33%
Gender
Females 6 20.00%
Males 24 80.00%
Site
Perineum 17 56.66%
Extremities 13 43.33%

Majority of the patients belonged to the age group of 40 – 49 years amounting to 36.66% followed by more the 60 years age group constituting 23.33% followed by 50 – 59 years age range with 20% and the least belonging to the 20 – 29 years age group with 6.66%. Majority of the patients were male amounting to 80% and the rest 20% were females. In 56.66% of the patients the site of NF was perineum and in the rest 43.33% of the patients it was in the extremities.

Table 2: Treatment for necrotizing fasciitis
Treatment Frequency Percent
Debridement 20 66.66%
Amputation 1 3.33%
SSG 7 23.33%
Permanent colostomy 1 3.33%
Testis Placement 1 3.33%
Total 30 100.00%

In majority of the patient’s line of treatment done in around 66.66% was debridement, followed by SSG in 23.33% then equally followed by Amputation, permanent colostomy and testis placement constituting 3.33% each.

Table 3: Bacteriology – Gram positive and gram negative bacteria
Bacteriology (Gram Positive) Frequency Percent
Staphylococcus 2 6.66%
Streptococcus 1 3.33%
Group A streptococci 7 23.33%
Coagulase negative Satphylococcus 1 3.33%
Bacteriology (Gram Negative)
E.coli 5 16.66%
Proteus 2 3.33%
Citrobacter 2 6.66%
Klebsiella 3 10.00%
Non fermenting bacilli 1 3.33%
Enterococci 1 3.33%

The gram-positive bacteria found in the patients were staphylococcus, streptococcus, group A streptococci and coagulase negative staphylococcus. The gram-negative bacteria found in the patients were E. coli, Proteus, Citrobacter, Klebsiella, Non fermenting bacilli, Enterococci.

Table 4: Type of Bacterial Culture and Histopathological finding of NF
Type of Culture Frequency Percent
Polyculture 27 90.00%
Monoculture 3 10.00%
Total 30 100.00%
Histopathology
Positive 9 30.00%
Negative 21 70.00%
Total 30 100.00%

The type of bacterial culture done was polyculture in majority 90% of the patients and monoculture was done in the rest 10% of the patients. 30% of the patients tested positive for NF and rest 70% were found to be negative with NF

Table 5: Outcome of the study
Outcome Frequency Percent
Died 9 30.00%
Survived 21 70.00%
Total 30 100.00%

Out of 30 patients 9 patients constituting 30% died and the rest 21 patients constituting 70% survived.

Discussion

Necrotizing fasciitis, although not common, can cause notable rates of morbidity and mortality. Necrotizing fasciitis has an occurrence of 1,000 cases per year and a worldwide frequency of 0.040 cases per 1,000 person-years. [2] It is important to have a high index of suspicion and increase awareness in view of the paucity of specific cutaneous findings early in the course of the disease. Prompt diagnosis and early operative debridement with adequate antibiotics are vital. Today, necrotizing fasciitis is an uncommon disease process yet one that must be recognized and dealt with rapidly. If not treated promptly and aggressively, the virulent and toxin-producing bacteria, most commonly group Streptococcus pyogenes, will cause severe systemic toxicity which may lead to death. Common risk factors include diabetes mellitus, immunocompromised states, peripheral vascular disease, cardiac disease, obesity, intravenous drug use, alcohol use, malnutrition, smoking as well as corticosteroid use and chronic use of non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs. [3,4,5] Despite the large number of predisposing factors that have been identified, half of all cases of necrotizing fasciitis occur in healthy individuals. Early surgical intervention preventing a delay of more than twenty-four hours prevented an adverse outcome.

All our patients were managed in ICU with aggressive fluid resuscitation and early and prompt debridement in all patients. They were treated with 4th generation cephalosporins, aminoglycosides, metronidazole and multiple debridement’s were done and frequency of dressing was twice daily.

Majority of the patients belonged to the age group of 40 – 49 years amounting to 36.66% followed by more the 60 years age group constituting 23.33% followed by 50 – 59 years age range with 20% and the least belonging to the 20 – 29 years age group with 6.66%. Majority of the patients were male amounting to 80% and the rest 20% were females. In 56.66% of the patients the site of NF was perineum and in the rest 43.33% of the patients it was in the extremities. The gram-positive bacteria found in the patients were staphylococcus, streptococcus, group A streptococci and coagulase negative staphylococcus. The gram-negative bacteria found in the patients were E. coli, Proteus, Citrobacter, Klebsiella, Non fermenting bacilli, Enterococci. The type of bacterial culture done was polyculture in majority 90% of the patients and monoculture was done in the rest 10% of the patients. 30% of the patients tested positive for NF and rest 70% were found to be negative with NF.

Mortality rate was 30% and deaths were due to sepsis, acute respiratory distress, Multiple organ syndrome, Infective dysfunction syndrome and metabolic encephalopathy. In a study by Czymek et al., the mortality was significantly higher among females (50% F vs. 7.7% M), [6] but in larger clinical studies, female sex did not seem to affect mortality. [7]

Morbidity was 10% involving amputations, Disarticulations, Colostomy, Placement of both testes in anteromedial sides of thigh, Bilateral orchidectomy, split skin grafting’s leading to contractions. In a clinical study performed by Anaya et al., the lower extremities were mostly affected (57.8%), [8] accompanied by the abdomen and perineum. Goh et al. [9] calculated the prevalence of diabetes mellitus in patients with NF at 44.5%, It is unclear that diabetes mellitus impacts the mortality rate.

Conclusion

Necrotizing fasciitis does not need any predisposing conditions to be prone to, it can happen to anyone young, old, child, any race, any size, healthy or not. The nature of early NF and its non-specific clinical signs can considerably delay the diagnosis. Delay in the diagnosis by a matter of hours significantly increases mortality. Operative treatment delayed by few hours shown increased mortality. Low serum sodium and histopathological evidence are the hard signs to clinch the diagnosis. Any two of the following factors at presentation indicate grave prognosis: Shock at presentation, Delay of 24 hrs. before hospitalization, Anemia, hypoproteinemia and Increased blood sugar levels. Effective and vigorous surgical debridement, often in multiple sessions, supplemented by adequate antibiotics and supportive treatment, is the key to a successful result with necrotizing fasciitis.